Click for Mac Memory Upgrades!
Click for Mac Memory Upgrades!


A Click shows your site support to my
Sponsors
Accelerate Your Mac! logo
Bottom Line Railgun 250/166/1MB G3 CPU Card Review
Review date: 5/03/98
Applications performance tests and comments
Intro | Benchmarks  | Appl. Tests | Software Controls  | Documentation | Specifications | Summary
Applications/General use comments

As is standard for my recent reviews, I ran timed applications tests in Bryce 2 and Infini-D 4.0. I used standard sample files provided with the applications. I chose these two applications because:

  1. There is no human timing errors possible since the application reports the total time to complete the test.
  2. They represent CPU intensive tasks of varying durations.
  3. They are very popular and therefore are likely to be used by many people reading this review.

I'm sure some of you will ask why I didn't run the full range of tests (as done with many other G3 cards) but to be honest I'm buried in work and email. The two tests I've run were very CPU intensive and of sufficient duration to be valid comparisons of performance. In general they also are less influenced by other system variables such as disk speed (unlike Photoshop which hits the swap disk on almost every operation, even with large amounts of RAM allocated to the program).

I know many of you would like to see more but I'm doing the best I can at the moment considering I'm answering about 6 hours of support mail a day, 7 days a week.

 

Infini-D 4.01 Tests

I used the same Infini-D tutorial file (chapter 7 completed) rendering test as I've done in past reviews. Rendering quality was set to Ray Trace, medium anti-aliasing, shadows on, patch detail low.

The table below shows the results at several CPU and cache speeds. The stock PowerTower Pro 180 (604e @180 Mhz), PowerForce 220/110, MacTell 266/266 and the XLR8 266 G3 cards results are also shown for comparison. Other G3 CPU cards I've reviewed were tested with Infini-D 4.0 and showed a large difference in times from v4.01, so I felt the version change made any comparisons to those results invalid.

 

Infini-D 4.0 Test Results
CPU Card/Speed:

Time

(Cache Size)
Railgun 250 @312/208

48:50

1MB
Railgun 250 @292/194

51:57

1MB
Railgun 250 @250/166

1:00:32

1MB
MacTell 266 @266/266

54:13

1MB
MacTell 266 @300/300

47:46

1MB
XLR8 322/214

47:23

1MB
XLR8 300/300

47:54

1MB
XLR8 266/177

57:14

1MB
PF220 @291/116

58:11

512K
PF220 @240/120
(No L3)

1:07:18

512K
Stock PTP 180

1:54:07

1MB

Notice that the G3 cards saved as much as 1 hour of rendering time compared to the PTP 180 on the rendering time for the Infini-D tutorial chapter 7 (finished) file. You can decide for yourself it the difference in performance is worth the cost of the upgrade, or for the higher priced cards. For more details on the other cards shown, see my complete list of CPU card reviews at the www.xlr8yourmac.com.

 

Bryce 2 Tests

I ran tests in Bryce 2 using the sample scenes in the KAI folder called "Magical Knight I" and "Alexandria II". Bryce 2 was left at the default memory allocation of 16980k.

Since my version of Bryce 2 is the same now as it was for all the other CPU card tests I've done, I listed more cards here for comparison, including the fastest 604E I've tested, a PowerLogix PowerBoost Pro 233 running at 263 Mhz with a 1MB L2 Rapidcache. The results with the stock PowerTower Pro 180 system is also shown.

Bryce 2 Test Results
CPU card:

Magical Knight I

Alexandria II

(Cache Size)
Railgun 250 @312/208

3:31

4:47

1MB
Railgun 250 @292/194

3:46

5:08

1MB
Railgun 250 @250/166

4:24

5:59

1MB
Mactell 266 @300/300

3:34

4:52

1MB
Mactell 266 @266/266

4:04

5:32

1MB
XLR8 322/214

3:29

4:46

1MB
XLR8 300/300

3:40

5:03

1MB
XLR8 266/177

4:12

5:47

1MB
Newer Tech 266/166

4:06

5:39

1MB
Newer Tech 275/275

3:58

5:29

1MB
PowerForce250 @292/292

3:46

5:10

1MB
Newer Tech 250/166

4:28

6:08

512K
PF220 @291/116

3:52

5:14

512K
PF220 @240/120

4:37

6:16

512K
PB Pro 604E @263Mhz

4:46

6:33

1MB
Stock PTP 180 604E @180Mhz

6:37

9:04

1MB

Note in the above tests, the PowerForce 220, MacTell 266 and XLR8 G3 cards used no motherboard cache. The Newer Tech cards were run with the motherboard cache disabled.

For reviews of all the cards listed - see my CPU card review list at the main site.


Since applications performance was very good, I rated this category a 9.


The next page describes the software cache control supplied with the card. Or you may use the links below to jump to a specific page.


Index of Railgun 250/166/1MB G3 Review Pages

Intro | Benchmarks  | Appl. Tests | Software Controls  | Documentation | Specifications | Summary

- or -
Back to WWW.XLR8YOURMAC.COM


Copyright © Mike, 1998.

No part of this sites content or images are to be reproduced or distributed in any form without written permission. All brand or product names mentioned here are properties of their respective companies.

Users of this web site must read and are bound by the terms and conditions of use.