Click for Data Doubler kits!
The Source for Mac Performance News and Reviews
Comparison Tests: Rage128 PRO vs Rage128
Most G4/AGP system owners looking to upgrade to the Rage128 Pro are probably most concerned with the performance gain with 3D Games, which has been somewhat of a sore point with the Rage128 in the past, at least at resolutions over 640x480. The good news is the Pro does deliver noticeable gains over the previous card - the bad news is that it's still to slow for 1024x768 mode 3D games in most cases. In Quake3 for instance even the cursor was very sluggish on the intro screens at higher resolutions, especially in 32Bit mode. 32Bit mode is needed to avoid the very poor image quality in 16Bit mode - the 'buzzing bees' effect I mentioned in my OpenGL update to the iMacDV SE review (see apps/game test review page for image samples) and Mac 3D Card Round Up article last fall.
32Bit OpenGL mode looked great in Quake 3 and was playable (at least solo) at 640x480 with the default test settings (dynamic lighting, lightmap, etc.). However I noticed even the cursor in the main game screens was very sluggish at 1024x768, 32Bit mode. However even 32Bit mode, RAVE games like Unreal and Unreal Tournament showed banding (dithering rings) in flares/light halos and fog. In both Unreal and UT, 32Bit mode also seemed to be prone to 'pauses', or a lack of fluid movement in some parts of the timedemo tests.
Game Settings: Rather than fill this already table-heavy page further - I used the same game settings as shown in all my Video card reviews with these games and also listed on the Entry Page of the Mac Game/Video Card Performance (FPS) database. The information on how to run these tests is noted in the FAQ's Game topic area.
The tables below show the average frames-per-second for both cards at 640x480 and 1024x768. In some games where possible, I've also listed the minimum and maximum framerates reported during the tests. In all cases the % gain for the Pro card is shown.
|Quake3 Arena 16Bit||640x480||1024x768|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||38.90||25.60|
The same tests were run in 32Bit mode.
|Quake3 Arena 32Bit||640x480||1024x768|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||36.80||20.30|
Quake 1 RAVE version 1.09 was used to test framerates in this least demanding of the Mac 3D first-person games. As with all my video card/game tests with Quake1, the "Flames", "Shadows", and "Filtering" options were enabled. As noted previously, remember you have to exit and restart Quake1 to have resolution changes take effect.
|Quake1 Rave Timedemo 1||640x480||1024x768|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||83.70||37.30|
Quake 2 tests were run using the same settings I normally do for all video card reviews. (No 8 Bit Textures, no Vsync, High detail textures, low audio/CD audio disabled). All results are in frames-per-second, higher is better.
|Quake 2 OpenGL Demo 1||640x480||1024x768|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||67.60||32.30|
The standard Unreal castle flyby 3rd loop average test was used. For consistency, I used the Unreal.ini files noted on the game FPS database Entry page and used in all my video card review/game tests. (For 32Bit mode tests, the ini file had the 'colorbytes' variable set to 4 vs 2.) All results are in frames-per-second, higher is better. Since the Unreal timedemo stats reports min, max and average framerates, all are listed below.
|Unreal 16Bit||640x480 AVG FPS||1024x768 AVG FPS||640x480 MIN FPS||1024x768 MIN FPS||640x480 MAX FPS||1024x768 MAX FPS|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||49.50||30.20||19.2||13.21||110.93||53.66|
The same tests were run in 32Bit mode.
|Unreal 32Bit||640x480 AVG FPS||1024x768 AVG FPS||640x480 MIN FPS||1024x768 MIN FPS||640x480 MAX FPS||1024x768 MAX FPS|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||49.39||29.24||19.6||12.81||105.22||51.05|
The 'cityintro' timedemo was run in Unreal Tournament full version with the 405 update applied. All settings were at their defaults (high detail, low audio) except the min desired framerate was set to 30 (not 20 as the default). All results are in frames-per-second, higher is better. Since the UT's timedemo stats reports min, max and average framerates, all are listed below.
|Unreal Tournament 16Bit||640x480 AVG FPS||1024x768 AVG FPS||640x480 MIN FPS||1024x768 MIN FPS||640x480 MAX FPS||1024x768 MAX FPS|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||39.20||25.57||21.9||13.08||84.25||54.54|
The same tests were run in 32Bit mode:
|Unreal Tournament 32Bit||640x480 AVG FPS||1024x768 AVG FPS||640x480 MIN FPS||1024x768 MIN FPS||640x480 MAX FPS||1024x768 MAX FPS|
|Rage128 PRO AGP||35.25||21.77||19.6||13.58||79.01||41.24|
32Bit mode in Unreal and UT especially seemed sluggish and still had the dithering/banding evident in flares and fog at least in the Castle Flyby and Cityintro areas. Remember these tests were run in high quality mode so reducing the game's texture and detail settings would show better performance.
Related Links: For over 1,200 (and growing) records of Mac Game/Video card performance with most every system and video card - search my Mac Game/Video Card FPS database. For other graphics card reviews and articles, see the www.xlr8yourmac.com video cards page.
The next page of this review covers tests in MacBench 5.0, RaveBench, Photoshop 5.5 scrolling and a QT Movie playback.
- or -
Back to WWW.XLR8YOURMAC.COM
Copyright ©, 2000. All Rights Reserved.
No part of this sites content or images are to be reproduced or distributed in any form without written permission.
All brand or product names mentioned here are properties of their respective companies.