|Status on Independent Project to Develop|
OS X SoundBlaster Live Drivers
Updated: 9/30/2005 (status info)
and 12/28/2005 (link to project page)
(Update - 12/28/2005) Brian sent a link to his current web page on the Mac SBlive OS X driver project
(Update - 9/30/2005) After a reader mail on a Petition to Creative Labs for OS X SoundBlaster Live drivers, I wrote Brian Souder (formerly of Creative)
about the current status of the independent development of Sblive OS X drivers. Here's his reply:
"The project is at a stand still because of Apple. I plan to post all
of my research to the new website, but if Apple does not want us
hooking into Core Audio, there is not much I can do. I think we
might be able to get the mixer working, but the card would not
utilize all of the features of the Live or even an Audigy.
There are already complete solutions out there doing more than what I could get
working. (i.e. M-Audio's 5.1 and 7.1 PCI cards. See Audio
articles page for links to reader reports on them.-Mike)
You can tell Apple is not keen on this with M-Audio as
well. Every time there is an OS X update, it breaks their card. So
they are probably doing some sort of hack to get things working
right. They just have people that have programmed audio cards
before, so they know more about it.
I have been hearing more and more people trying to develop for the platform getting frustrated
with Apple. We are even having problems with MuVo Helper in the new
XCode with backward compatibility. It seems like Apple wants to
force people on to OS X 10.4 and the new Intel systems. We may have
to do a separate build of the app just to maintain compatibility with
OS X 10.3...
(I asked if he was a member of Apple's developer program
and if the apple dev. docs on core audio didn't have the
info he needed.-Mike)
A lot of the stuff you really need are closely guarded. Like the
iTunes Plugin info for audio players. It is not available to just
anyone. You submit to Apple for the info and then sign an NDA. Then
they decide if you are worthy of having the information. The biggest
problem with the core audio is that we need apple to make the changes
we need to really hook in. There is no way to do accelerated audio
at all without them. They did not seem to think there was any reason
for it. Natahan and i got into a pretty heated argument with them
The most common question I am getting is "now that Apple is
going to intel based processors - will the SB Live work now". The
lower hardware stuff would not really change - it is the same problem
- interfacing with core audio. Some of the stuff seems pretty
obvious - like the sliders for the mixer - etc. The data passing,
playback, acceleration are where the problem lies. Nathan could
elaborate on this more. I am guessing this is the part that breaks
on the M-Audio cards every time Apple updates OS X. I would love to
make this work if someone can figure out how to do it. I thought the
guys from Germany had it all worked out, so originally I was letting
them run with it. Then they just disappeared. So then Nathan,
Chuck, and I tried to tackle it.
Overall, the documentation was not very good either from Apple. Some of it ran in circles, and like you
said, in some cases you need to be a premier developer (costs $$$) to get the
rest of it. I was paying for this project out of pocket, so that was
not going to happen. I want to reassemble the project with people
willing to donate time to develop it, but it is kind of dead in the
water now. I have all the research in ring binders in my storage unit.
BTW - I am no longer with Creative Labs, but
I still have all of my resources. I plan to put a whole section up
dedicated to all the people that wanted a driver.
(as of today I didn't see anything at www.tg-cg.com related to OS X SBlive drivers
and Brian later wrote:)
I will try to put something up this weekend specific to the SB Live.
Right now it is the MuVo Helper and iTunes Plugin for Mac.
I asked he send a note when the site is updated with the SBlive/OS X info.
(original info from July 2002 follows)
On July 17th, 2002 Brian Sounder of Creative Labs posted a thread here on his independent (not supported by Creative) effort to develop OS X drivers for the Soundblaster Live. (I know that's a touchy subject to SBlive owners that bought the card after problems seen even with the OS 9 drivers ... but just posting it as a FYI that someone is trying to get OS X drivers done.)
"I am starting this thread to keep you guys up to date on my SB Live for OS X driver status until I get the web site up. At the moment, this project is completely independent of Creative, but I hope to change this in the future. I have a small group of programers helping me with the coding. When I get the web site up, I will probably open up a BETA TESTERS registration form. If you are interested in looking at the accumulated documentation, you can find
it on my mac.com account:
(Link Posted Later When .MAC is rolled out)
My latest info is that the inputs are now working on the drivers I am putting together with some other people. I have not run the driver myself yet, so don't get too excited yet. They are optimized for 10.2, and the first Beta may not be far off. Initially it will only give you basic I/O. They are going to be put together modularly so that we can
re-use code to possibly do an Audigy card driver later on.
I received additional information this morning that they have some of the PCM channels for sound output working, and they are currently trying to bind the volume sliders to their respective addresses on the card. One of the programmers is on vacation this week, but things should continue moving forward as planned.
They also reported that the card has an extremely low latency. This may be because there is very little work being
done by the card, but hopefully the trend will continue. The code is being optimized for OS X 10.2 (? - Jaguar), but
apparently works on previous versions of the of the OS - I would imagine only back to 10.1.0 since Apple added a
lot of the audio stuff in that release.
NOTE TO PERSPECTIVE USERS:
When we get the basic I/O working, you will be able to start using the card again. Many of the advanced features will be added over time. One of my goals is to add an auto update feature to the software like Apple's Software Update. Hopefully this will make it easier to pull in new features, as they become available.
As with any BETA software, I would recommend that you have a separate OS X partition to test on. While I am a Creative employee, Creative does not have anything to do with these drivers and WILL NOT support them at this time. Remember you will be using these at your own risk, so I would seriously not have anything valuable on the
same drive in case you have to reformat.
Creative One (aka Brian)"
OWC XYM SPECIALS!
= UPGRADES by Mac =
Upgrades just for
= Refurb Mac Pros =
(Click for List)
SSDs from under $50!
Fast SSDs for Most Macs/PCs
= ThunderBolt =
Drives, Docks & More
= HARD DRIVES =
Up to 12TB HDDs
HGST, WD, Seagate, Toshiba
= 2.5in HDs & SSDs =
Notebook Hard Drives and DIY drive/case kit bundles
= MEMORY =
Lifetime warranty RAM Upgrades!
= OPTICAL DRIVES =
Internal and External Superdrives/Blu-Ray drives
= VIDEO / DISPLAY =
Graphics cards, Displays, Adapters, Cables & more
= AUDIO ITEMS =
Interfaces, Cables, Software, Speakers, Headphones & more
= SOFTWARE =
Apps, Utilities, OS, VM, Games and more
= WIRELESS =
WiFi and Bluetooth Devices/Adapters/More
= Repair Service =
for iPhone, iPad, Macs
= iPad/iPhone/iPod =
Accessories, Cases, Repairs & More
NuGuard iPhone Case *Extreme* Drop Tested!