Click for MiniStack Ext. Drives with Powered FW/USB Hubs!
Click for MiniStack Ext. Drives with Powered FW/USB Hubs!


Keep this site growing - Please visit my Sponsors

Accelerate Your Mac! Logo

WallStreet PowerBook G3 Comments
(from Reader Feedback- updated 5/31/98)


Here's two reader's impressions on the new Wall Street PowerBook G3/250/13.3"

Steve writes:

" Well, after visiting Creative Computers every 2-3 days for a while to no avail I decided to try CompUSA in Fox Hills, Calif. (a bit further from my house) to play with a Wall Street. The salesman didn't know what a Wall Street was. I told him it was Apple's new line of PowerBooks. He seemed surprised. The two 1400s they had on display were locked up so I rebooted them. They each froze in the exact same position they had been in, unable to complete a reboot. The older G3 PB offered anyone who knew the password a chance to enter it. In an hour I spent there trying to help a girl with a PB 540c who claimed to have bought it from the singer Seal, not one salesman set foot in the Apple store within a store. The G3 desktops were in better shape, but people had no one to help them or answer questions. They had some software but I couldn't even find a copy of RAM or Speed Doubler for the girl.

So I went even further from my house to Fry's Redondo Beach. Eureka! There were two 233 MHz models. A 12.1" and a 13.3" No one disturbed me as I tested the 13" for 40 minutes.

First of all, it's HUMUNGOUS. Disturbingly large for someone who opted for a Duo after having a PB 100 and a PB 180c because I was tired of schlepping all the weight around. Secondly, the screen is beautiful. Spacious and bright. I think it's brighter than any other PB screen I've seen. I've always noticed that at this Fry's (and many other computer stores) the abundance of fluorescent lights make the notebook computer screens look worse than in any other conditions except direct sunlight. Well it didn't phase this beast at all. In fact I turned the brightness down to less than half. There was no contrast button on the active. There was on the passive. Whatever extra it costs to get an active is well worth it in my opinion. There was marked submarining of the cursor on the passive and the viewing angle was only good directly in front of it and less than a head to each side of center. The active has a much wider viewing angle but not all the way to the edge of the screen. One or one and 1/2 heads off of center.

The resolution was fixed on either machine. 600 x 800 on the 12". 1,024 x 768 on the 13". I was concerned that type would be too small for comfortable reading on the 13". I like to set a large font in SimpleText, ClarisWorks and browsers when I read from the screen. Paltino 18. (For printing I use Geneva 12) My Duo 2300c and PowerWave (with 15" monitor) are set at 640 x 480 and I'm very comfortable reading off their screens. Well, at the store, after setting the fonts on SimpleText and IE 4 to Palatino 18 , I found them to be a little smaller than what I'm used to but very acceptable. Not tiny print. When I use the keyboard on a notebook, my face is closer to the screen than when I use my big monitor at home, so this makes up for some of the lost size.

But for my personal taste, the icons in the finder and the icons and fonts in the menu bar are too small. I didn't try adjusting the fonts in the finder, but usually when I try this they get too coarse. And the icons in the menu bar and the folder and trash icons can't be enlarged to satisfy me. It would, I think, take concentration not to occasionally miss your target when moving things. But the comfortable reading size is a more important issue and I'm glad that's not a problem as that could cost Apple a sale from me.

The keyboard: The letter keys are huge. Bigger than the ones on the small Apple keyboard that came with my Quadra 605 (or did I buy it separately?) So that will take some getting used to. I hunt and peck but I have developed some muscle memory about where keys should be and on the Wall Street I occasionally hit the key next to the one I was seeking because they are so large. Also, when I get a good thought going, I really start pounding the keys rhythmically. The keys on the Wall Street seemed to have a shorter distance to travel before hitting bottom and while they seemed able to tolerate my pounding, they seem like they are more set up for a softer, touch typist. I suppose I could adjust to hitting the keys a little less hard.

If you've got a huge screen that displays millions of colors, you want to look at some graphics. Unfortunately, the pickings were very scarce on this box. The Cancun sunset that was selected as the desktop picture looked magnificent. I did a search for .jpg files. A brightly colored baboon's nose showed off the screen well but it was small. I did a search for .mov files and came up with the QTVR Japanese Garden that's part of the Intro to Mac OS (or whatever it's called) that you view from within a browser.

Speed: The 233 is a pretty snappy, though not blazing machine. It seemed to load Web pages from the hard drive (I had no access to the net) quite fast, which of course is a measure of drawing to the screen. I had no huge movies to test it with. I of course compared it to my Duo with a 100 MHz 603/no cache which it creamed of course. They're not in the same league at all. And I compared it to my 200 MHz 604e/57 MHz bus on the PowerWave. The PowerWave, I would say, feels a little faster. That makes sense if you compare the @445 MacBench CPU score of the Wall Street to the 557 MacBench CPU that my 'Wave gets. But for what I do, I don't miss having a G3 in the 'Wave. The fact that the 233 Wall Street is close means it's pretty fast. (Especially for the price.) I suspect that the 250 MHz Wall Street, which MacBenches 881, and the 292's 1,031 score would be *very* impressive. Can't wait to try them.

Heat: The bottom of the 13" was quite hot, though not to an alarming degree. The bottom of the 12" was cooler, but I had not been using it so that might be why.

The clicker below the trackpad was not as pleasing to me as the one on my Duo or the one on my PB 180c. But *far* better than the one on the PB 2400 which I don't like at all.

Aesthetics: I have been really excited about the Wall Street since I first started seeing pictures of them a few months ago. A few weeks ago I downloaded some Super Hi Rez pictures of every angle from Apple's PowerBook Gallery. Almost daily I have opened these pictures in Photoshop and drooled over them. From the photos, the top cover and the palmrest put me in mind of leather. The sides and back, with their glistening black material, their ominously glowing infrared eyes, and their shark like vents, put me in mind of Steath Bombers. Well, I found the real thing a little disappointing in comparison. The cover on top is not even grey rubber for a good grip as I had supposed. It's fairly slippery plastic. And it had some greasy fingerprints on it. The palmrests and everything else were just black plastic. Not unlike that used in the PB 2400. I have to give credit to the photographers hired by Apple. Somehow, they lit these babies to bring out a texture in the plastic that I didn't see in real life.

But it is a gorgeous shape. No question about it.

Summary: I think I would still like one for the awesome screen, the speed, and the full set of features. (The infrared will be a great way to transfer files. The millions of colors, the hot swap-able devices, the easily upgradeable RAM and hard drive and the function keys are great, as is the long battery life [if not exaggerated] ) But it is a too large and heavy for my taste. And, like a photoshoot in Penthouse or Playboy, the flaws are artfully hidden and the models are shown only in the best light.

That said, the flaws are few, the plusses are many, and especially when the price drops a bit, these puppies will be a *big* part of putting Apple in a much better financial position. Hey, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that out. It'd be a good time to buy Apple stock.

Take Care,
Steve"


Adrian Miranda writes:

" I got to play with a new Powerbook G3(250 13").Apple Aust has not launched it here yet but the service centre had an evaluation unit for them to get familiar with and the Techie was kind enough to let me into the inner sanctum to have a play. In one word, wow. Since I suspect you may be a lover of the portable powerhouse I'll give you my impression.

The screen was crisp, sharp and had fantastic colour saturation. There were no artifacts or ghosting. When we played a Quicktime clip on full screen it played fast and there were hardly any jerks in playback, Fantastic.

The keyboard was crisp and sharp in feel. Unlike the original G3 there was no sponginess or flex. All the keys were well layed out and the inverted Y arrow keys were a well addedfeature. Only complaint is that the inverted T keys and the return keys were significantly smaller and would take getting used to.

Dimensions wise it is a really slim machine. Kinda like the duo but it had a rather large footprint. If you are used to the smaller footprint of earlier PBs this will take some getting used to especially in terms of hand positioning. The internal battery was also very slim. About 1/3 that of the original G3. The power adaptor... about 1/3 that of the original as well.

The machine was able to run with both media bays used by the floppy and CD. Apparently they are hot swapable and bay independent.

In the original G3 my biggest complaint was that the rear door that covered the connections used to either fall off or break at the slightest bit of preassure applied. In the new one, it is spring loaded. To break it would be impossible in normal usage.

I terms of looks, move over Cindy Crawford. There is not an unsightly line in the whole thing (although I actually prefer the rainbow apple logo to the clear one). It flares slightly at the palm rests ala the 1400 and the closing latch is a lift up one so no chance of breaking it as well. In terms of speed. Very snappy. Apps opened quick and video was also fast. One of the guys tried Quake on it and I must say I was impressed.

Keep in mind this is only the 250 Mhz one. Imagine what the 292 would be like. Maybe I should sell my 9600 and present G3.......

Best regards,
Adrian Miranda "


Thanks to Steve and Adrian for sending their comments.

Back to XLR8YOURMAC.COM

Your Source for the best in CPU/SCSI/VIDEO card reviews, daily news, and more! 


Copyright © Mike, 1998.

No part of this site's content is to be reproduced in any form without permission. All brand or product names mentioned here are properties of their respective companies.

Disclaimer: Users must read and are bound by the Site Terms & Conditions of Use.